Health Care

Video ruling could be short-lived

Video ruling could be short-lived”

Unlike in some other states, video from police dash cameras is not widely available in Pennsylvania, largely because police agencies have deemed the information to be exempt under the Right-to-Know Law and the Criminal History Record Information Act.

The case was filed by Michelle Grove, who requested a copy of the police report as well as any video or audio recordings pertaining to the auto accident in Potters Mills, about 15 miles east of State College.

State police had argued the videos should be exempt under the Right-to-Know Law and a state law limiting access to criminal records.

In a decision that opens up public access to police videos, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court has ruled state police dash camera footage of the aftermath of a vehicle crash must be released under the state's Right-to-Know Law.

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court on Tuesday ruled that royalties from oil and gas leases on state forest land must be dedicated to conservation of the Commonwealth's public natural resources, not used for general budgetary purposes.

Grove's lawyer, Helen Stolinas, said the ruling was "a decisive victory for the citizens of Pennsylvania and the press to remain aware of the activities of state and local officials and be able to scrutinize how public servants are performing their duties", according to the Associated Press.

The Supreme Court's ruling upholds decisions by Commonwealth Court and the state Office of Open Records that granted a Centre County woman's request for state police dashboard video camera recordings of a auto crash in which her friend was involved. "They have to prove that's the case", Ready said.

The Supreme Court went on to note that according to Pennsylvania's law in effect at the time the amendment was passed, proceeds from the sale of trust assets must be returned to the body of the trust, which, in this scenario, would mean the proceeds must be used to further preserve Pennsylvania's natural resources.

Gov. Tom Wolf has generally expressed support for the bill in the past.

Senate Bill 560 creates a new procedure for public access to police recordings that Melewsky called onerous.

The decision said the only part of the recordings that is potentially investigative was the audio from witness interviews - portions that had been ordered redacted by a lower court.

Chief Justice Thomas G. Saylor and Justice Sallie Updyke Mundy disagreed with the majority, filing their own opinions that said regardless of whether videos lead to the filing of criminal charges, they are part of the troopers' investigative process. An agency spokesman said the case was under review.

Grove appealed to the state's open records office, which granted her request.

Like this


24 June 2017
WPX Energy, Inc. (WPX) hit his 1-Year Low price on 06/27/16
Scotiabank reissued a "buy" rating and set a $20.00 target price on shares of WPX Energy in a research note on Tuesday, June 13th. The company's shares were assimilated at $13.35 per share worth to an investment of some $66,750 on account of LOWRIE WILLIAM G .

24 June 2017
North Korea FINALLY reacts to claim it tortured U.S. prisoner
He declined to give names or titles and said it was at "another location in NY ". (AP Photo/John Minchillo). Tillerson and Secretary of Defense Jim Mattis hosted Chinese State Councilor Yang Jiechi and Gen.

24 June 2017
Appeal expected; jury awards $218M to Kan
But China, a major importer of USA corn, had not yet signed off and rejected shipments of corn that contained the new traits. The case concerned Syngenta's Agrisure Viptera and Agrisure Duracade, corn seeds containing genetically engineered traits.

24 June 2017
PM Nawaz, Russian President Putin meet in Kazakhstan
There has been speculation about a possible meeting between Modi and Sharif in Astana to ease the growing tension between the two neighbours.

24 June 2017
Protests against Sharia law across the country; Milwaukee Muslims offer alternative
Seattle police say they are prepared for two protests - one against Sharia and the other pro-Muslim - in downtown on Saturday. And on the other side of the street, dozens of protesters wearing face masks and carrying red and black protest flags.

24 June 2017
Police arrest man in connection with fatal motorcycle crash
Once officers located the auto , they determined that the car's damage was consistent with the crash that they were investigating. Perez, who was uninjured, lied to police about his name, the release said, and he said the vehicle was his but he wasn't driving.

24 June 2017
Timberwolves acquire Butler from Bulls in blockbuster trade
There will be other contending teams, such as San Antonio or Houston, with space under the cap to pay them more than the Cavs. After a disappointing first season overseeing the operation, Thibodeau grabbed a fully grown pit bull to toughen the team up.

24 June 2017
Middlesbrough defender still keen to leave club
And The Telegraph's report suggests the interest from Rafa Benitez's side is now more concrete. Stoke City have dismissed reports that they have offered Middlesbrough £12m for Ben Gibson .

24 June 2017
Scientists find massive disk-shaped dead galaxy
This is a surprise because elliptical galaxies contain older stars, while spiral galaxies typically contain younger blue stars. Objects in the distant universe appear small and hard to see - unless they're sitting behind a cosmic magnifying glass.

24 June 2017
Timberwolves get Jimmy Butler in trade with Bulls
Dunn had great promise coming out of the draft , but his entire profile was built on him being older and being ready to play now. His rehabilitation has gone well, but the injury certainly complicated the Wolves' re-engaging Chicago on Butler.