Worldwide

Justices side with government in property rights case

Justices side with government in property rights case”

In delivering the opinion of the court, Justice Anthony Kennedy said the family had not been deprived of all economically beneficial use of their property. In recent decades, property rights advocates have aggressively tried to limit regulation by demanding compensation.

However, under state law, if abutting, commonly owned lots don't each have at least one acre of developable land, they together constitute a single, buildable lot. The rules were created to prevent too much development along the St. Croix River.

The Murrs wanted to sell the lot next to their cabin, but were denied a county land variance to separately use or sell their two adjoining lots. The lots were later transferred to his children in the 1990s. Under the regulations, they could build a house that was bigger than the existing one, but they could not have two houses on the two lots which now were considered merged into one.

"We will continue the fight for property owners and for the integrity of the constitutional right against uncompensated government takings", he continued.

The family appealed to the Supreme Court, arguing that separate property interests, even if adjacent and owned by the same person, can not be combined to determine claims of whether property has been taken through regulation. But today the justices ruled in favor of the regulators.

The 5-3 ruling on Friday involved the Murr family's effort to sell part of its land along the St. Croix River.

"The provision.at issue here was for a specific and legitimate objective", he observed.

Holmes made that statement in the very opinion that first established the concept of a regulatory taking. They planned to use the proceeds from an empty lot to pay for improvements on a cabin that sits on adjacent land. In the end, he said, the loss in the value of the Murrs' land was only about 10 percent.

Roberts said he disagreed with the majority's analysis of other factors besides state and local law, including physical characteristics of the land and its prospective value.

"This is an unfortunate decision for the Murrs, and all property owners", said John Groen, PLF's Executive Vice President and General Counsel.

William Treanor, Dean of Georgetown University Law Center, said the decision would have a profound effect in cases involving wetlands. The ruling could make it harder for property owners to prove compensation claims. Courts must strive for consistency with the central objective of the Takings Clause: to "bar Government from forcing some people alone to bear public burdens which, in all fairness and justice, should be borne by the public as a whole.".

TOTENBERG: Harvard Law School's Richard Lazarus calls the decision a huge victory for government regulators and environmentalists.

"There is no nuance to the ruling", he said.

The case was closely watched by property rights and business groups that say it should be easier for landowners to get compensation when government regulations restrict land use. "It just looks at the most environmentally sensitive part, and restricts your use of that piece".

The ruling (PDF) came three months after the court heard oral arguments in Washington, D.C. The justices agreed with lower courts that the county's regulations meant to limit development on the lower river did not illegally deprive land-owners of its value.

Roberts acknowledged that the test he suggested might have ended up with the same result, meaning the regulations at issue would not have amounted to a taking of private property, and the Murrs would not have qualified for compensation.

Justice Neil Gorsuch, who joined the court after the case was argued, did not participate in Friday's decision.



Like this

Latest


26 September 2017
Explore Fort Tilden State Park: An Abandoned New York City
As you approach the boat graveyard, as its name is, there are about more than 100 extinct vessels that rest in the relative peace. But in the recent years, it had gone from an obscure stretch to a favorite destination among the beachgoers and lovers as well.

13 September 2017
Top Bookmakers Name Odds-On Favourites for 2017-2018 NBA Championship Success
As a result, the Warriors won the championship for a fifth time, taking back the title that they last won as recently as 2015. The two teams have met in the final for three consecutive years, with the Cavs picking up the title just once, in 2016.

26 June 2017
Microsoft unveils their 4K console Xbox One X at E3 2017
Xbox boss Phil Spencer was interviewed about the new console, saying the PS4 Pro is an Xbox one S competitor, not an Xbox One X. Microsoft has finally launched their ambitious bid to claim the lead in 4K gaming with the launch of Microsoft Xbox One X.

26 June 2017
Baby in Coma for 5 Days Dies in Brooklyn; Father Remains Jailed
Nylah's aunt Christine Munford recalled the little girl as a source of joy - and reviled the jailed father as a source of pain. Her mother Tammy Lewis, 17, dropped her off to spend quality time with him, in spite of the promises Shaquan Taylor, 18, made.

26 June 2017
Coyotes acquire Stepan from Rangers
The 27-year-old played in 81 games for NY last campaign, tying a career high with 55 points on 17 goals and 38 assists. Stepan joins the Coyotes with four years remaining on a contract that pays him $6.5 million per season.

26 June 2017
North Korea conducts test of rocket engine that could power an ICBM
A missile to reach the United States mainland is in development but it's not clear what stage the project is at. The test also coincides with intelligence reports that North Korea would test a nuclear device .

26 June 2017
Amazon deal slams retailers as Dow edges to record
Customers are assigned a personal shopper who scours the aisles, purchases and delivers items from retailers like Whole Foods . The shift started within minutes of the announcement online retailer Amazon would taking over the grocery chain Whole Foods .

26 June 2017
Turkey refuses closing military base in Qatar upon Arab states' demand
According to the list, Qatar must refuse to naturalize citizens from the four countries and expel those now in Qatar . Qatar has slammed the blockade as an "illegal siege" based on "false allegations on financing of terrorism".

26 June 2017
Death toll in Pakistan oil tanker accident rises to at least 153
The hospital, which is treating numerous wounded, added that over 100 people were injured in the explosion, in a statement Sunday. Reports from the scene suggested the truck had been speeding, while some say it was trying to make a sharp turn when it flipped.

23 June 2017
Marvel Looks To Shake Its Poor Gaming Reputation
The games are well designed with attractive graphics and extensive content, but neither is viewed as a flawless experience. These games tend to be actually well done for what they are, and in a way they’ve been the pride of Marvel gaming.



Recommended