NEB can fulfill duty to consult, but must do so meaningfully

NEB can fulfill duty to consult, but must do so meaningfully”

"That's guidance on a go-forward basis, but I don't think there's anything there that is going to have a significant impact on the Trans Mountain litigation", he said.

Clyde River community members in Ottawa for the ruling will hold a news conference late Wednesday morning.

In an admirable job of balancing competing rights, which is how rights work in a just and pluralist society, the high court set out sensible ground rules to enable resource projects to take place on lands in which indigenous peoples have treaty rights and must be consulted.

The Supreme Court noted that accommodations recorded by the NEB's environmental assessment report after limited Inuit participation included things like putting community liaison officers in communities affected by the testing and the design of an Inuit Qaujimajatuqangit (Inuit traditional knowledge) study but said this was not enough.

Yet the consultation "fell short in several respects" the court found.

"In this case, in light of the scope of the project and the consultation process afforded to the Chippewas of the Thames by the NEB, the Crown's duty to consult and accommodate was fulfilled", wrote a unanimous court.

But Akeeagok and Kotierk still aren't sure exactly what those implications will be.

Clyde River is an Inuit community on the northeast coast of Baffin Island.

In that case, the Supreme Court ruled that the community was adequately consulted on Enbridge's plans.

There are some lessons and some comfort for everyone in the decisions the Supreme Court of Canada made Tuesday in two cases where resource development projects were pitted against Ottawa's duty to consult indigenous communities whose treaty rights might be affected.

However, in the second case, seismic testing near Clyde River in Nunavut, the court found the energy board had disregarded treaty rights of the Inuit people when it proceeded to test in marine areas protected under the agreement without analyzing the effect it would have on the community.

At the same time, Clyde River did get some "nominal funds" from QIA, Natanine said.

A few months later, the companies filed a 3,926-page document in answer to those questions - but the vast majority of the massive data dump was not translated into Inuktitut. "There's so many different layers to the difficulties that people face to be able to participate in something like this", Kotierk added.

The judgment of the supreme Court thus puts an end to the oil project.

"The government can not continue to pay lip service to reconciliation and Indigenous rights while continuing to ignore the duty to consult and accommodate".

"The consultation process here was, in view of the Inuit's established treaty rights and the risk posed by the proposed testing to those rights, significantly flawed", the ruling said.

"The Trans Mountain process is very much the way the NEB does oil pipeline hearings, which is very much the way they did Line 9", Schultz said, noting Kinder Morgan is preparing for construction of the long-awaited mega-project.

"This decision means everything to the Inuit, seismic blasting is an existential threat", Nader Hasan, the lawyer representing the Inuit nation, said.

The NDP government in B.C. had previously vowed to "employ every tool available" to stop the pipeline, but B.C. attorney general David Eby recently said the province would not artificially delay permits for the pipeline because "we'll be sued".

Like this


27 July 2017
Firefighters rescue woman trapped in auto by flash flooding in KC area
A section of southbound Interstate 35 between Interstate 635 and 18th Street Expressway was closed because flooding. Indian Creek was cresting over the road bridges at every intersection, topping 27 feet at its highest.

27 July 2017
UP RERA website gets over 15000 complaints on Day 1
Planning To Buy A House? The Haryana Cabinet on Tuesday approved the Haryana Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Rules. Besides, only a handful of states have so far launched the websites for online registration.

27 July 2017
BCCI adopts all Lodha reforms expect five having 'practical difficulties'
However, the Lodha panel had recommended that the majority of the power should be in the hands of the CEO. Interestingly, Choudhary insisted that the board has accepted all the recommendations.

27 July 2017
From one champion to another: Sania Mirza hails 'incredible ambassador' Mithali Raj
The Ashes is the only regular Test fixture in women's cricket while other teams mainly play the shorter formats. Raj said Indian Railways played a huge role in giving support to the players through jobs.

27 July 2017
Windows Bounty Program Offers Up to $250K Per Bug
Rewarding security researchers with bounties costs peanuts compared to paying for a serious security snafu. And payouts from $500 to $250,000 is one heck of an incentive to go looking for bugs.

27 July 2017
Boeing Reports Strong Earnings in the Second Quarter
Other hedge funds have also added to or reduced their stakes in the company. 137 funds opened positions while 378 raised stakes. The company's cash from operations, at almost $5 billion in the quarter, was roughly double estimates of about $2.5 billion.

27 July 2017
Comcast Q2 Earnings, Revenue Top Views Amid Verizon Speculation
At Comcast's cable business, earnings rose 5.4% to $1.956 billion in the quarter as revenues rose 5.5% to $13.12 billion. At the NBCU cable networks, earnings rose 11.7% to $1.055 billion as revenue rose $5.1% to $2.7 billion.

27 July 2017
Free hepatitis testing at Seminole County health department
It is transmitted through contaminated blood transfusions, needles and in some patients the cause is unknown. It can be both acute and chronic, ranging in severity from a mild illness to a lifelong one.

27 July 2017
ED registers money laundering case against Lalu Prasad, family
Criticising Nitish Kumar, Shivanand Tiwari, a close confidant of Lalu Prasad, said: "I know Nitish Kumar for the last 40 years". The ED on Thursday registered a money laundering case against the Lalu Yadav in the railway hotel allotment corruption case.

27 July 2017
Marlins outscore Rangers 22-10, set franchise record for runs
The first four Marlins reached on two doubles and two singles before Darvish recorded his first out of the inning. Rangers: Before a weekend series at home against Baltimore, the Rangers have a day off Thursday.