Worldwide

UK's top judge says government must provide legal clarity on Brexit

UK's top judge says government must provide legal clarity on Brexit”

It states that courts in the United Kingdom will "not be bound by any principles laid down, or any decisions made, on or after exit day by the European court" and will no longer be able to refer matters to EU courts after that date.

Currently Britain must abide by ECJ judgments but Prime Minister Theresa May's government has said that Britain will leave its jurisdiction after Brexit.

In an interview with the BBC, the Supreme Court president said ministers had to outline what must be done to incorporate European Union law for judges, otherwise they would be required to "do their best" without any proper guidance.

"However, we want to provide maximum certainty so the Repeal Bill will ensure that for future cases, United Kingdom courts continue to interpret EU-derived law using the ECJ's case law, as it exists on the day we leave the European Union", she said.

Lord Neuberger said all judges "would hope and expect Parliament to spell out how the judges would approach that sort of issue after Brexit, and to spell it out in a statute". The best way to deal with the post-Brexit extradition system is to mirror the Norway-EU extradition agreement, whereby Norwegian courts implement a "constant review" of the relevant decisions by the European Court of Justice without such decisions being binding. "Basically, we will do what the statute says".

"We're incorporating large amounts of European law into our own law to ensure continuity but how is that to be interpreted thereafter?"

"Lord Neuberger is highlighting [that] it's far from clear, when you look at the legislation, what you're asking the judges to do".

"There must be a recognition that the ECJ does not have a remit to tell United Kingdom citizens what to do".

But Lord Neuberger, who is Master of the Rolls, said that was not clear enough and he said Parliament must be "very clear" in spelling out how British courts should react to landmark judgements in the ECJ.

"What he's saying is there's no point in those circumstances turning round at some subsequent point and saying "well, the judges are interpreting this in a way that is causing us, for example, difficulties".

In the Repeal Bill, which the British government managed to narrowly get through Parliament with the support of MPs from the Democratic Unionist Party, it says British courts would not have to follow rulings made by the ECJ but "may do so if it considers it appropriate".



Like this

Latest


09 August 2017
30 civilians killed in US-led airstrikes in north Syria
It said 14 of the dead were members of one family, adding the toll could rise because of the number of critically wounded. More than 330,000 people have been killed in Syria since the conflict began with anti-government protests in March 2011.

09 August 2017
Berenberg Bank Boosts Taptica International Ltd (TAP) Price Target to GBX 560
Taptica International Ltd Ord Nis0.01 Di had 10 analyst reports since September 25, 2015 according to SRatingsIntel. Shares of Taptica International (TAP) traded up 2.53% during midday trading on Monday, reaching GBX 405.00.

09 August 2017
AQR Capital Management LLC Decreases Stake in Douglas Dynamics, Inc. (PLOW)
Blackrock Advsrs Llc owns 12,031 shares or 0% of their USA portfolio. 113,400 were accumulated by Bridgeway Capital Mngmt Inc. Finally, American International Group Inc. boosted its position in shares of Douglas Dynamics by 7.1% in the first quarter.

09 August 2017
Donald Trump 'given daily dossier of positive news about himself'
The positive notices are culled by staffers from the Republican National Committee. You can read the full report on Trump's "Propaganda Document" here.

09 August 2017
Sebi's diktat leaves 331 suspected shell companies out in the cold
The regulator in a August 7 circular to stock exchanges said these companies will not be allowed to trade this month. These companies holding in any depository account will be frozen till the delisting process is completed.

09 August 2017
New federal report finds strong link between climate change, human activity
The draft report estimates that human impact is responsible for a Fahrenheit increase in global temperatures of 1.1 to 1.3 degrees from 1951 to 2010.

09 August 2017
Chandigarh stalking case: Police summon accused BJP leader's son
Vikas was arrested after Varnika filed a complaint with the police. She had also alleged that Vikas tried to open her auto door. We have received the police notice ( to Vikas).

09 August 2017
PDP Southwest Leaders Demand Disciplinary Action Against Senator Buruji Kashamu
Eddy Olafeso said the anti-party activities of some of the PDP members led to loss of elections in Ondo, Ogun and Edo states. The governor's spokesperson described Kashamu's loyalists, who met yesterday in his hotel in Lagos, as pseudo-PDP members.

09 August 2017
Tyrone Crawford has sprained ankle, will be ready for Week 1
Because of that turnover in the secondary, a versatile defensive lineman like Crawford has added value for the Cowboys. Crawford, 27, had 4.5 sacks last season and was credited with 17 quarterback pressures.

09 August 2017
David Silva agrees Las Palmas deal?
He has already rejected several lucrative offers from Spain as he is committed to his current City deal. In that time, the midfielder has also won two European Championships and the World Cup with Spain.



Recommended