Culture

Abuse royal commission recommends changes to confession rules

Abuse royal commission recommends changes to confession rules”

Catholic clerics should face criminal charges if they do not report sexual abuse disclosed to them during confession, an Australian inquiry recommended on Monday.

Australia's Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse - the nation's highest form of inquiry - recommended that all states and territories in Australia introduce legislation which would make it a criminal offence for people to fail to report child sexual abuse in an institutional setting.

Outside Australia courts around the world have grappled with whether religious confession should be privileged.

The commission says the importance of protecting children from sexual abuse means there should be no exemption for clergy over information received during a religious confession, despite the Catholic Church believing the confessional seal must not be violated. "Outside of this all offences against children must be reported to the authorities, and we are absolutely committed to doing so", said Hart in a statement.

If such a law was actually imposed in Australia, priests would ostensibly have to choose between following criminal law or canon law, which forbids them from revealing anything they hear during confession.

He said should Australia's parliaments change the law, priests would be expected to obey the law, like everybody else, or suffer the consequences.

The CEO of the Australian Catholic Church's Truth Justice and Healing Council, Francis Sullivan, said the seal of confession is one of the universal laws of the church.

It said the commission had heard evidence of multiple cases where abuse was disclosed in confession, both by victims and perpetrators.

He said that while the Church and the TJHC had consistently argued that reporting provisions should not apply to the confessional, the Royal Commission had now made a different determination based on information and evidence it has heard over the past four years.

"The risk to children of perpetrators of child sexual abuse going unchecked, or religious confession enabling a pattern of ongoing offending, is not displaced by the uncertain gain of perpetrators receiving guidance or possibly being persuaded to report to the authorities in religious confession". The right to practise one's religious beliefs must accommodate civil society's obligation to provide for the safety of all and, in particular, children's safety from sexual abuse. However, it remains possible that information about child sexual abuse held by people associated with a relevant institution is communicated to a priest hearing a religious confession. How that law has been applied since then, though, is unclear; Australia's Royal Commission noted in its report that the issue has yet to be tested in Ireland's courts.

The commission wants all jurisdictions to have a failure to protect crime, given evidence that perpetrators continued to abuse children after being moved between the institution's schools or other sites following allegations.

"The criminal justice system is often seen as not being effective in responding to crimes of sexual violence, including child sexual abuse", the report said.



Like this

Latest


14 August 2017
Auburn names Jarrett Stidham starting quarterback
Stidham and the Tigers will kick off the regular season on September 2 against Georgia Southern. The Auburn Tigers have named a starting quarterback for the 2017 football season.

14 August 2017
'Penalties are coming': Minister puts householders with vacant second home on notice
The Attorney General has been asked to examine if new powers of compulsory purchase are needed to help tackle the housing crisis. Minister for Housing, Eoghan Murphy , unveiled on Monday morning, a plan to progress the delivery of vacant homes back into use.

14 August 2017
Iranian drone comes close to US aircraft carrier: US Navy
Jeff Davis previously told reporters that there had been 35 incidents of such behavior by Iranian vessels and aircraft in 2016. This latest incident is the second within a week that involved a drone interacting unsafely with USA carrier-based aircraft.

14 August 2017
Justin Bieber Is Dropping a New Track Called 'Friends'
We were like, how in the world did he see this random post? "We only had 70 followers and had posted 5 times previous to this". "Who is that girl? In ur latest post", Bieber wrote, adding a heart emoji, according to Gober's screenshot of the message.

14 August 2017
Khloe wants to Wednesday again
The star had nothing but praise for current boyfriend #Tristan Thompson and spoke candidly about marriage and children. Khloe Kardashian has declared her relationship with Tristan Thompson "the best" she's ever been in.

14 August 2017
Jaguars WR Lee carted off field, Fournette shut down
If Fournette struggles to stay healthy in his rookie year, the Jags will have to turn once again to Chris Ivory and T.J. Marrone told reporters Sunday the team was "being careful with him" after the running back's foot injury was confirmed.

14 August 2017
Drunk air passenger arrests up 50%
The arrest figures obtained by Panorama came from 18 out of the 20 police forces with a major airport in their area. Unite called for an action plan to "stem the tide of drunken and disruptive behaviour".

14 August 2017
Charlottesville vehicle attack suspect remains behind bars as judge denies bail
James Fields, 20, of OH , didn't enter a plea on Monday during an appearance in his jail cell before a Virginia judge. He described Fields as being "fairly quiet", "smart", and also an open admirer of Adolf Hitler and the Nazis.

14 August 2017
Philippines suspends Uber for a month
It was found that Uber and Grab have around 42,000 active drivers, but only 3,700 have valid provisional authority or franchise to operate.

14 August 2017
Ice Cube Defeats LaVar Ball in BIG3 4-Point Challenge
Ice Cube had challenged Ball in May to the contest, saying he would buy 10 of Ball's Big Baller Brand sneakers should he lose. In the end, though, Ball wasn't able to live up to his boastful words.



Recommended