Economy

More Than Half of Cancer Drugs Have No Effect on Patients

'There is a clear need to raise the bar for approving new cancer drugs, ' said Huseyin Naci of LSE.

The study, performed by researchers from the United Kingdom and Latvia, evaluated the availability of evidence on survival and quality of life benefits of drugs that had been approved by the EMA between 2009 and 2013.

Apart from dashing patient hopes, allowing unproven medicine onto the market also unnecessarily exposed people to toxicity inherent in all drugs, while inflating state pharmaceutical spending.

The research team analysed reports on cancer approvals by the European Medicines Agency (EMA) from 2009 to 2013.

The study was published online Thursday in the journal, BMJ. Well, it turns out many patients would be no better off taking a placebo.

Lead author of the study Dr Courtney Davis, a medical and political sociologist in the Department of Global Health and Social Medicine at King's College London, explained: "We evaluated the evidence base for all new drugs entering the market over a 5 year period and found that the majority came onto the market without clear evidence that they improved patients' survival or quality of life".

Since most cancer drugs cost about $100,000 per patient per year, it is not surprising that cancer is one of the most costly diseases to treat.

"The US Medicare programme is legally required to pay for any drug approved by the FDA without negotiation on price".

Furthermore, for those drugs that did show improvement in overall survival (24 out of 68, 35%), the benefits turned out to be limited, with a median of 2.7 months of life prolongation and a maximum of 5.8 months.

Even when drugs did show survival gains over existing treatments, the benefits were marginal, the study said. Questioned by AFP, the european medicines Agency has noted that they "extensively discussed the evidence supporting the anti-cancer drugs" and be open to any "new debate" on the subject.

Reactions of outside experts were mixed.

Of 23 indications whose survival benefit could be scored with the ESMO-MCBS tool, the benefit was judged to be clinically meaningful in less than half (48%). For the remaining 49% (33) there was uncertainty over whether the drugs extended survival or improved quality of life.

For Winette van der Graaf of The Institute of Cancer Research, the level of evidence required for drug efficacy "is very hard to obtain" in the case of rare cancers, "meaning that these patients would find it extremely difficult to gain access to new treatments", if regulators were less flexible.

In a linked editorial, Professor Vinay Prasad, of Oregon Health & Science University, said findings showed that the European Union system was "broken" and taking some decisions which were "absolutely unjustifiable".

Researchers said drugs were being passed for use across Europe on the basis of indirect measures - such as showing that medication had a biological effect on the body - rather than actual proof they could benefit patients.



Like this

Latest


06 October 2017
NY Sen. Gillibrand Blasts Congress After Las Vegas Shooting
He doesn't appear to have had a record of mental illness or criminal activity. "You know, I thought Sandy Hook would". Chris Murphy, D-Conn., echoed Kelly's sentiments saying, "It's time for Congress to get off its a- and do something".

06 October 2017
Powerful Storm Killed Seven People in Germany
At least four people were dead after Germany was hit by a heavy storm "Xavier" that caused heavy damage and traffic disruptions. A police representative also confirmed the death of a truck driver who was killed by a falling tree in his vehicle.

06 October 2017
Farmers stripped, thrashed in police station in Madhya Pradesh
The director-general of police has been asked to institute an enquiry and submit a report within three days, he said in Bhopal . The farmers had gathered outside the district collectorate and were trying to meet the collector with a list of their demands.

06 October 2017
National Rifle Association open to regulation of 'bump stocks'
He issued his own proposal for gun control: "First, take the guns away from the criminals-disarm them first". The device replaces the standard rifle stock, which is held against the shoulder.

06 October 2017
Amit Shah brings political murders to the fore in Kerala rally
The CPI (M) Kerala state secretary Kodiyeri Balakrishnan took a dig at the BJP president describing Amit Shah as a toothless lion. Kerala party chief told the media that Shah is scheduled to re-join the yatra on Thursday.

06 October 2017
Feds carefully avoid criticizing Spain over referendum crackdown
The EU, which remained virtually silent on the Catalan issue for weeks , will hold a special debate on Wednesday on the matter. Their main goal was to show Madrid and the global community that hundreds of thousands of Catalans support independence .

06 October 2017
Honeypreet not cooperating, may ask to further remand: Panchkula Police
He claimed that the Haryana government and police had failed to take cognisance or act on the information. The Haryana Police on Thursday took Honeypreet to the Panchkula Sector-20 Police Station for questioning.

06 October 2017
Frank Martin: Lamont Evans' Arrest "Broke My Heart"
Evans was also a student assistant and a graduate manager at Kansas State during Martin's tenure from 2008 to 2011. Evans was sacked from Oklahoma State shortly after he was bonded out of jail.

06 October 2017
Lewis Hamilton reveals Mercedes boost in Japan as Malaysia problems fade
Lewis Hamilton splashed gingerly to the fastest time of a soaking second session after an absorbing morning run-out in Suzuka. Esteban Ocon was "best of the rest", taking seventh quickest for Force India whilst Sergio Perez could only manage 13th.

06 October 2017
Terrorists Strikes Shiite shrine in Pakistan's Balochistan, Killing 20
SSP Jhal Magsi Muhammad Iqbal said five children, a woman and one police officer were among those 20 people killed in the bombing. In April, about 20 people died in a suicide attack at a Sufi shrine near the city of Sargodha, in Pakistan's Punjab province.



Recommended