Worldwide

Terror Liability Troubles Kennedy, Conservatives At High Court

The court's four liberals indicated that corporations should not be immune.

The case at hand grew out of terrorist attacks carried out by Hamas and other groups between 2004 and 2010 during the Second Palestinian Intifada, the Arabic word for uprising. Claiming that the Jordan-based Arab Bank sponsored the violence by processing $2.5 million in payments at its New York City branch, relatives of some 6,000 foreign victims filed suit in Brooklyn.

The court has wrestled before with the kind of lawsuits authorized by the Alien Tort Statute, which was enacted by the first Congress in 1789.

Kagan appeared sympathetic with this point, and elsewhere in the argument said the bank has "plenty of things to gripe about", in this case. Her comments raise the possibility that the justices could reach a compromise, concluding this case may not proceed in an American court given its weak connection to the US while saving the question of corporate liability for another day. "I think the question is do you have something to gripe about as to this particular point, which is corporate versus individual liability".

Chief Justice John Roberts said he was concerned that corporate liability would cause "foreign entanglements", alluding to the Trump administration's contention the case has caused friction with the Jordanian government. But he urged the justices not to adopt a categorical rule that corporations may never be sued under the 1789 law.

"Norms control behavior", said Kennedy, who usually serves as a tiebreaker in cases split along party lines. But she added that corporate liability was not one of them. "That seems to me to be a norm".

Justices Samuel Alito and Neil Gorsuch also questioned whether corporations could be sued.

Human rights advocates say the ATS is an essential vehicle for corporate oversight and accountability.

A law adopted by the first Congress in 1789 called the Alien Torts Statute (ATS) allows US courts to hear cases involving foreign nationals for "violation [s] of the law of nations or a treaty of the United States". "In the two years after Kiobel", he said, "over 70 percent of those cases were dismissed on extraterritoriality grounds, and another 10 percent were dismissed for other reasons". Royal Dutch Petroleum Co.

But that room narrowed in Kiobel where Nigerian plaintiffs had accused foreign oil companies of aiding atrocities against villagers in the Ogoni region carried out by the Nigerian military and police forces. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the 2nd Circuit in NY agreed with that position. "If suits like this were taken away, Israel and countries like it might well have a complaint to the United States".

Arab Bank disputes this, saying the transactions occurred entirely overseas, with no money being transmitted through the U.S.

"Imagine Israel's view if our entire finance system could be used and accessed to commit terrorist attacks, make them easier, make them more deadly, make the funding more effective", he said. The organization, they claim, helped "identify, locate, and pay the families of suicide bombers and other terrorists".

The lead plaintiff in the Arab Bank case is Joseph Jesner, whose British citizen son was killed at age 19 in a 2002 suicide bombing of a bus in Tel Aviv.

Before coming into vogue in the 1980s, the Alien Tort Statute had been gathering dust for centuries. It reads: "The district courts shall have original jurisdiction of any civil action by an alien for a tort only, committed in violation of the law of nations or a treaty of the United States".

"So, there is an American corporation", she said, beginning her hypothetical.



Like this

loading...
loading...

Latest


27 March 2018
The Growth of Online Gaming and Betting Companies
Even though brick and mortar casinos make offers to gamblers, they do not come anywhere close to what is offered on the wide web. Alternatively, they can be used to learn about the game and the features it comes with as well as the strategies that work best.

12 October 2017
Pretium Resources, Inc. (PVG) Raised to "Outperform" at Scotiabank
The Firm is engaged in the acquisition, exploration and development of precious metal resource properties in the Americas. However, 8.52% over the last one month, -0.10% for the last quarter and year to date performance stands at 17.48%.

12 October 2017
Stock under Discussion: Eldorado Gold Corp (EGO)
This is the price at which the trader or investor wants to exit his existing position so he can realize the most reward. There are advantages to using a moving average in your trading, as well options on what type of moving average to use.

12 October 2017
Company stock datas that defines today's share market: Cardinal Health, Inc. (CAH)
The stock of Cardinal Health Inc (NYSE:CAH) has "Outperform" rating given on Thursday, February 11 by RBC Capital Markets. It has underperformed by 21.65% the S&P500. ( CAH ) by 92.81% based on its latest 2017Q2 regulatory filing with the SEC.

12 October 2017
Jordan Brand ending Carmelo Anthony's signature sneaker line
A report from ESPN's Nick DePaula late Tuesday said that Anthony's signature sneaker line is getting stopped by Jordan Brand . Are you upset to see the Jordan Melo line come to an end? "I would've done it for free because I loved working with Melo".

12 October 2017
Knicks jerseys to be sponsored by Squarespace
And the irony of the Knicks signing a deal with Squarespace was not lost on some. "We're excited to have Squarespace as a part of our team".

12 October 2017
IN emphasizing 'confidence' as No. 17 MI looms
IN is 1-4 ATS in their last 5 games at home, 1-5 in their last 6 conference games, and 2-5 in their last 7 games on field-turf. Defensively, Michigan football yields 13.6 points and 213.0 total yards (126.0 in passing and 87.0 in rushing) per game.

12 October 2017
Indian forces martyr three Kashmiris in gun battle
The fighting started when soldiers searching for militants cordoned off a neighbourhood in the northern town of Hajin. Sources said that two militants also made an appearance at the funeral.

12 October 2017
Stock Levels in Focus for PennyMac Mortgage Investment Trust (NYSE:PMT)
They expect this year's earnings to fall -73.33% year-over-year to -$0.04, followed by -150% decline in the next year to $0.02. The stock of Barracuda Networks Inc (NYSE:CUDA) has "Buy" rating given on Thursday, August 31 by KeyBanc Capital Markets.

15 September 2017
ShangriLa is online casino with guarantee of won money pay outs
Shangri La proposes games for any taste A large selection of slot games allows anyone to choose a game for any discerning taste. This is the best place to spend your free time with pleasure, stress relief, relax and forget about the daily problems.