Culture

Review of state capture remedial action will test public protector's powers

Review of state capture remedial action will test public protector's powers”

The case relates to claims that Zuma was influenced by the wealthy Gupta family to appoint and dismiss ministers in accordance with their interests or to secure lucrative government contracts.

Zuma took issue with the remedial action and applied to court to have it reviewed and set aside.

He argued that a commission of inquiry was the only effective way to investigate the allegations in a public and credible way and was the public protector's best attempt to cure the root cause of the complaints.

Ishmael Semenya told the court in Pretoria that former Public Protector Thuli Madonsela had overstepped her powers in ordering the president to set up a commission of inquiry led by a judge appointed by the chief justice. It would give the chief justice five days to name a judge to head up the inquiry, after which Zuma would have 15 days to establish the commission.

Economic Freedom Fighters lawyer, advocate Tembeka Ngcukaitobi, told the court that "no one could be a judge in their own court", and thus it would be improper for Zuma to appoint a judge to oversee the inquiry.

"If he (Zuma) is acting in the public interest, he would not resist the involvement of the chief justice", Mpofu said.

"The President did not make pronouncements in front of his friends".

He said Madonsela was well within her rights to ask Zuma to establish a commission of inquiry.

Mpofu said Zuma has a duty to uphold, protect and defend the constitution and to assist the public protector to ensure there is no maladministration, and to ensure that matters like these are dealt with without delay.

Zuma should not use the courts to reverse his commitments on complying with statements he had been making in public, he said.

In Mkhwebane's heads of argument, she hit back, citing "an exceptional case" and said it was "impossible for him to do so [retain control over who is appointed] lawfully because he is implicated in the subject matter of the commission".

"The remedial action has made that choice for me as head of state, this is impermissible", he said.

Adv Dali Mpofu, for the UDM and Cope, argued the president was playing blatant gymnastics to avoid the simple matter of an investigation and to let the public know if there was criminality in the highest office in the country.

Mpofu agreed with Ngcukaitobi's submissions that Zuma "could not be the judge in his own case".



Like this

loading...
loading...

Latest


25 Октября 2017
Cop celebrates child's birthday after child is left at school
A Green Bay police officer is being praised after he picked up a child from school - left alone on his birthday. A police officer went out of his way to help a Green Bay boy feel special on his birthday.

25 Октября 2017
Federal Bureau of Investigation adds NC murder suspect to 'Most Wanted' list, offers $100G reward
He has ties to Phoenix and may reside in San Francisco de los Romo, Aguascalientes, or Pabellón de Arteaga, Aguascalientes. The FBI announced Tuesday that 18-year-old Alejandro Rosales Castillo was added to their "Ten Most Wanted Fugitives" list.

25 Октября 2017
Kate Steinle murder trial underway
Bureau of Land Management ranger who reported that it had been stolen from his parked vehicle a week before Steinle was shot. Earlier in the day, Michelle Lo testified about walking past Garcia Zarate as he sat on a swivel chair on the pier.

25 Октября 2017
Sabres look to keep momentum against Red Wings
They didn't need it this time, with Benoit Pouliot scoring the lone goal and the eventual victor midway through the second period. Detroit's losing streak now stands at five games.

25 Октября 2017
Man arrested for saying 'good morning' because online translator made a mistake
The man has since deleted his Facebook post and did not want to be identified, the Times reported . Around 500 are held under administrative detention, which allows imprisonment without charge.

25 Октября 2017
Singapore partners Hong Kong to boost fintech development
More details will be announced by the two authorities next month which will likely be at the Fintech Festival in Singapore which finews.asia will be covering as a media partner.

25 Октября 2017
Rivalry with Lionel Messi 'Just Starting,' Says Cristiano Ronaldo After FIFA Win
The legendary Italian stopper picked up the prize ahead of Real Madrid's Keylor Navas and Bayern Munich's Manuel Neuer. Voting for the bulk of the awards was equally weighted between national team captains and coaches, media and fans.

25 Октября 2017
Snapchat for Android now supports 60-second 'multi-snap' videos
If you are an avid Snapchat user then you are familiar with the recording feature and sharing of video clips within the platform. These include the covering of links beyond its original content and allowing you to briefly disappear from its Snap Map.

25 Октября 2017
NAACP issues travel advisory to African-Americans flying American Airlines
An African American woman on another New York-bound flight, this one out of Atlanta, said she and her infant were removed from the flight.

25 Октября 2017
Kuwait Emir warns Gulf crisis will escalate
Qatar has reaffirmed its commitment to resolving the ongoing GCC cconflict through dialogue and has called on other parties involved to do the same.