'Mental Health Is Your Problem Here'; Not So, Say San Antonio Advocates

'Mental Health Is Your Problem Here'; Not So, Say San Antonio Advocates”

Hours after the mass shooting in Sutherland Springs, President Trump took a firm stance on the violence, saying that he believed it was a "mental health problem".

Mental health advocates are exhausted of the automatic connection between mass shootings and mental illness. A lot of problems over a long period of time.

"This isn't a guns situation", Trump said.

And indeed, it appears most Americans feel the same way.

In February, Trump signed into a law a bill repealing an Obama-era policy created to limit access to guns among people with certain mental illnesses.

The U.S. Department of Health & Human Services (DHSS) says that people with mental health illnesses are no more likely to be violent than the population at large. NAMI is the National Alliance on Mental Illness. In short, Trump says this is a mental health problem, but his actions suggest otherwise.

"Mental health stakeholders are loath to have this conversation about improving mental health care in a context-driven by violence prevention because that's not why we need mental health reform per se", said Swanson. "The majority of people who have mental illness truly diagnosable mental illness are not violent people". "That is not two-plus-two-equals-four".

Jeffrey Swanson, a professor of psychiatry and behavioral sciences at Duke University who specializes in gun violence and mental illness spoke to the Atlantic about mental health and violence a year ago. She argues individuals who commit mass murder are motivated by something else and that treatment, no matter how available, might not be a viable solution.

"It's unsafe to do that in that we then condemn people for something that may not be their fault", she said. "Those type of people are not going to want to get help, they think they're right, even if we had all the funds in the world".

Michael Stone, a forensic psychiatrist at the Columbia College of Physicians and Surgeons who the Washington Post reported maintains a database of more than 300 killers, a lot of them shooters of four or more people, found that just about two out of ten mass killers were suffering from serious mental illness.

"The rest had personality or antisocial disorders or were disgruntled, jilted, humiliated or full of intense rage", the Washington Post went on to report.

Often the reaction when someone becomes a mass shooter is they must be mentally ill.

It should be noted neither Stephen Paddock, the Las Vegas shooter, nor Devin Kelley, the church shooting suspect, were known to have been diagnosed with a mental illness.

The shooting at the First Baptist Church, like so many other mass shootings in the United States, is not an inevitable result of someone having a "mental health issue". Download the 10News app now.

Like this


14 February 2018
Science contest Star Track, initiated by Max Polyakov, reveals new space genius
The Star Track competition is a brainchild of the Oles Honchar Dnipro National University and Noosphere Engineering School . Examples of similar projects include ARLISS, NASA Student Launch from the USA, as well as the European CanSat Competition.

09 November 2017
Visiting Yosemite will be easier on the wallet this weekend
Yosemite National Park , along with dozens of other national parks, are holding free entrance days during Veterans Day weekend. The other is November 24, a Friday picked to encourage the public to make an autumn visit to a state park.

09 November 2017
Sainsbury's first half profit dented by seasonal Argos loss
Group sales (excluding Value-Added Tax , including fuel) increased to 14.64 billion pounds from 12.64 billion pounds past year . Further, the company's board approved an interim dividend of 3.1 pence per share, down from 3.6 pence previous year .

09 November 2017
Centene Corporation (CNC) Updates FY17 Earnings Guidance
Edgestream Partners Lp decreased Spdr Dow Jones Indl Avrg Etf (DIA) stake by 1,427 shares to 3,965 valued at $845,000 in 2017Q2. The company reported $1.35 earnings per share for the quarter, beating the Zacks' consensus estimate of $1.24 by $0.11.

09 November 2017
Suspect in custody after incident at Publix in Winter Park
The driver, who was not identified, was charged with fleeing and eluding police and resisting arrest without violence. Police said the driver got out of the vehicle and ran through the Publix parking lot as officers gave chase.

09 November 2017
Analysts Set Cabot Oil & Gas Corporation (COG) Price Target at $29.44
If you are reading this news story on another domain, it was stolen and republished in violation of USA and global copyright law. Canada Pension Plan Investment Board holds 0.03% of its portfolio in Cabot Oil & Gas Corporation (NYSE:COG) for 522,698 shares.

09 November 2017
Tampa Bay Lightning at San Jose Sharks
The Sharks (8-6-0) saw their four-game winning streak end. "We didn't do anything well", coach Peter DeBoer said. San Jose D Marc-Edouard Vlasic rejoined the blue line after missing one game because of a head injury.

09 November 2017
Roman Abramovich sent SIX cars to sign John Obi Mikel
It was like a military operation, ' Mikel said during an interview with the Sun . Mikel saw his decision vindicated by a productive 11-year stint with Chelsea.

09 November 2017
HDFC Standard Life IPO oversubscribed 1.17 times on Day 2
According to merchant banking sources, promoters are expected to get about Rs 7,500 crore from the stake dilution. HDFC owns 61.65% and Standard Life 35% in the insurance company, while minority shareholders owns the ret.

26 September 2017
Explore Fort Tilden State Park: An Abandoned New York City
As you approach the boat graveyard, as its name is, there are about more than 100 extinct vessels that rest in the relative peace. But in the recent years, it had gone from an obscure stretch to a favorite destination among the beachgoers and lovers as well.