Worldwide

Judge Says Conservative Student Groups Can Sue UC Berkeley over Speech Restrictions

A free speech lawsuit against officials at the University of California, Berkeley can move forward, although there is no evidence the school discriminated against speakers with conservative views, a US judge ruled.

As discussed above, plaintiffs allege in the [first amended complaint] that the [high-profile speaker policy] includes no standards, either through the policy's terms or its history of enforcement, to limit any implementing officials' discretion; as plaintiffs further point out, the HPSP provides, for example, no standard for determining what events fall under the policy, at what locations events may be held, and what, if any, security fee may be imposed.

While she "questioned the constitutionality" of one provision that defines a "major event" in relation to its "complexity", that claim is now moot because the university revised the "complexity" provision in January, the judge said.

University officials repeatedly cited safety concerns for restrictions on subsequent conservative speakers, and Chesney said "there are no allegations suggesting those concerns were unfounded".

In February 2017, a speech by conservative speaker Milo Yiannopoulos at Berkeley was canceled after violent protests erupted on campus, resulting in fires and shattered windows.

Harmeet Dhillon, an attorney for the plaintiffs, said she disagreed with numerous aspects of Chesney's ruling, but it was still "bad news" for UC Berkeley.

Chesney found the university charged a much higher ($9,162) security fee for the Shapiro speech than it did for events featuring Supreme Court Justice and Obama appointee Sonia Sotomayor in the same venue, the report said.

"We are pleased that the court carefully considered the issues and upheld the Major Events Policy that the campus adopted previous year", Dan Mogulof, assistant vice chancellor of UC Berkeley's Office of Communications and Public Affairs, said in an email to Courthouse News. The lawsuit claims the college unconstitutionally suppressed conservative speech on campus.

Although Chesney said that she was "unpersuaded" that Berkeley discriminated against the conservative groups, she agreed that the groups can pursue an equal protection claim over the alleged security fees that the school charged.

It also denied it had a secret policy for high-profile speakers. Sather Gate is a historical entrance to the UC Berkeley campus.



Like this

loading...
loading...

Latest


27 April 2018
Macron defends new Iran nuclear plan, Trump outreach
But Tehran is in no mood for changes in the agreement. "Who allowed you to do that?" Iran is a real problem for this country. Slavin said that unlike Tehran, Islamabad does not have adversarial relations with the US, Israel or the Arab Gulf states.

27 April 2018
Sony Has Now Shipped Over 79 Million PS4 Consoles Worldwide
While this is a decrease from previous years, the company expects it to be offset by an increase in PlayStation 4 software sales. PlayStation Plus subscribers topped 34.2 million as of March 31, 2018, which is up 7.8 million from the previous fiscal year.

27 April 2018
Intel (INTC) Posts Quarterly Earnings Results, Beats Estimates By $0.15 EPS
Wall Street experts also assign a $54.03 price target on Intel Corporation, pointing towards a 5.16% rally from current levels. New Mexico Educational Retirement Board holds 0.79% of its portfolio in Intel Corporation (NASDAQ: INTC ) for 451,670 shares.

27 April 2018
Education Realty Trust Inc (NYSE:EDR) to pay $0.39 dividend
With 1.60 million avg volume, 5 days are for Brandywine Realty Trust (NYSE:BDN)'s short sellers to cover BDN's short positions. They just need to take the company's market capitalization and divide it by the company's total sales over the past 12 months.

27 April 2018
Ford 1Q earnings up slightly, company promises more savings
Despite the higher profit, Ford's adjusted pretax profit margin fell to 5.2 percent from 6.4 percent in the same quarter in 2017. The automaker says it made $1.74 billion, or 43 cents per share, compared with $1.59 billion, or 40 cents per share a year ago.

27 April 2018
Mohamed Salah might be honoured with plot of land in Mecca
The last few days have been filled with Mohamed Salah-fever, and you didn't have to be a Liverpool fan to be a part of it. Mane has been a key player for the Reds this year so they'll want him fit and firing for both games.

27 April 2018
Court verdict: Asaram Bapu convicted, quantum of sentence to be delivered soon
With so many charges against him, it was obvious he would not walk away freely from this and hence this final verdict is welcome. The parents of the two cousins alleged that they were killed in Asaram's ashram, where they claimed black magic was practised.

27 April 2018
As of May, 3 Astronics Corporation (ATRO) Analysts See $0.31 EPS
Therefore 50% are positive. 5 are the (NASDAQ:ATRO)'s ratings reports on April 27, 2018 according to StockzIntelligence Inc. The forecast of 1 surveyed investment analysts covering the stock advises investors to Buy stake in the company.

27 April 2018
Liverpool-Roma supporter clashes - two arrested, one in critical condition
Salah has scored 43 goals and assisted other 15 goals in all competitions for Liverpool this season, and Madjer was astonished with the way he grew since joining the Reds.

27 March 2018
The Growth of Online Gaming and Betting Companies
Even though brick and mortar casinos make offers to gamblers, they do not come anywhere close to what is offered on the wide web. Alternatively, they can be used to learn about the game and the features it comes with as well as the strategies that work best.