Local

Trump To Get Another Supreme Court Judge?

Trump To Get Another Supreme Court Judge?”

The Supreme Court on Friday ruled 5-3 that a Wisconsin family's adjacent, commonly owned properties must be considered a single parcel of land for the objective of analyzing the local government's taking of the property. "We will continue the fight for property owners and for the integrity of the constitutional right against uncompensated government takings". Three years later, the Murrs' parents bought an adjacent lot, which has stayed vacant since 1963.

So after the Murrs transferred the lots to their four children in the 1990s, the younger Murrs were denied permission to build on the second lot. Solicitor Misha Tseytlin said that legal link exists between the two Murr properties and that's what combines them into one in the government's eye.

The Trump administration placed former Kennedy clerks in prominent posts throughout the Department of Justice.

The Murrs eventually made a decision to sell the vacant lot.

Ellen Denzer, community development director for St. Croix County, praised the ruling.

The Fifth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution has a provision called the Takings Clause, which says that private property can not be taken for public use without fair compensation. The Murrs challenged the regulations in the state courts as an unconstitutional taking. While Thomas joined the liberal wing of the Court in concurring with the ruling, he did so because Cooper v. Harris mainly addressed racial and not partisan gerrymandering, the latter which he believed was impossible to limit in Vieth v. Jubelirer. The state, arguing against a taking, offered a different bright-line test based on state law taken as a whole; here, the state's merger provision would set the denominator as both lots together.

In any case, the implication that the legislature's composition should correspond to the party balance statewide smacks of a plea for proportional representation, which the Supreme Court has never supported. Pam, I keep thinking about an event you and I did two weeks ago when we talked about constitutional norms, and I wonder how it feels to be watching a court that looks to have had its norms-for the most part-back in place this June.

The U.S. Supreme Court, in agreeing Monday to hear a Wisconsin case on partisan gerrymandering, might force some hands wherever state legislators craft lines with the overriding goal of keeping their parties in power.

Rath said that's particularly true on the issue of abortion rights, with Kennedy taking a position that translates as narrowly pro-choice. The Supreme Court, for a century, has said that when the government goes "too far" in regulating property - so as to make that property economically unusable - the government also has to compensate the owner. Once applied, the dissent stated, this will push courts to define parcels in ways that align with "r$3 easonable government regulation", making it less likely that such regulation will be deemed a taking. Courts must strive for consistency with the central objective of the Takings Clause: "to 'bar Government from forcing some people alone to bear public burdens which, in all fairness and justice, should be borne by the public as a whole'".

The other two older justices, Ruth Bader Ginsburg, 84, and Stephen Breyer, 78, are Democratic appointees.

The biggest news of all, though, would be if Justice Anthony Kennedy were to use the court's last public session on Monday to announce his retirement.

The proper approach, he said, is to consider a number of factors when determining if a property owner should expect their property to be treated as one parcel or separate tracts.

"Whenever possible, governments in regulatory takings cases will ask courts to aggregate legally distinct properties into one 'parcel, ' exclusively for purposes of resisting a particular claim", he wrote. "And I have a lot of respect for that gentleman, a lot".



Like this

loading...
loading...

Latest


26 June 2017
Senate GOP's Plan To Repeal, Replace May Be In Trouble
Among other things, the bill would phase out the extra federal assistance that has added more than 210,000 Nevadans to Medicaid. It now covers about 70 million people, including children and able-bodied adults mostly served by private managed care plans.

26 June 2017
Such incidents should be stopped at earliest: Brinda Karat on Ballabhgarh lynching
As per reports, what was initially an argument over seats soon turned communal after the mob found out that they were Muslims. The Hindustan Times quoted the man , the only accused to have been arrested so far, as saying, "I was drunk".

26 June 2017
Phoenix Flights Cancelled Due to Extreme Heat
Caesars Entertainment, which operates the casino, said the birds aren't usually brought in unless temperatures exceed 120 degrees. Excessive heat warnings have been extended through at least the end of the week from Arizona to northern California.

26 June 2017
USA tech titans urge Trump to tackle skills gap
The American Technology Council, established by an executive order in May, signed by Trump, attracted 18 technology executives . No comment from Apple or White House so far. "The US should have the most modern government in the world".

26 June 2017
Lopez beats Cilic in nail-biting Queen's Club final
But in the third set Cilic rolled through his own service games and got the crucial break of serve in the seventh game. It proved to be a momentary lapse, and Cilic converted his second match point when fired down a second-serve ace.

26 June 2017
Bachelor in Paradise Has Ceased Production Due to 'Misconduct' Allegations
The bachelor or bachelorette also places blame on DeMario for "taking advantage" of Corinne , who was "drinking too much".

26 June 2017
AIADMK (Puratchi Thalaivi Amma) to support NDA in Prez poll
The parties are now learnt to be veering towards fielding a strong Dalit candidate of their own to take on BJP's Kovind. Shiv Sena and the People's Democratic Party, both NDA constituents, too, have pledged support to Kovind.

26 June 2017
Trump lashes out at Warren, calls her an 'overrated voice'
John Cornyn of Texas said there is "a sense of urgency" to push forward but acknowledged the outcome is "going to be close". Senate Republican leader Mitch McConnell of Kentucky and his colleagues are determined to get rid of it.

26 June 2017
Not 'that far off' from passing health-care overhaul
Joseph Lieberman (I-CT) and Collins discussed the release of a report that says that less than one percent of the 4,000-mile U.S. Trump was interviewed by "Fox & Friends", while Collins, Schumer and Paul appeared on ABC's "This Week".

26 June 2017
Family of Sam DuBose demands another retrial, calls for peaceful protest
Prosecutors broke down body camera video frame-by-frame to rebut Tensing's assertion that he was being dragged down the street. The prosecution argued Tensing was in no imminent danger but rather forgot his training and reacted in an unreasonable manner.