Worldwide

Supreme Court lashes Centre, MEA over delayed extradition of Vijay Mallya

Supreme Court lashes Centre, MEA over delayed extradition of Vijay Mallya”

Martin Lau, professor of law at the School of Oriental and African Studies, deposed on Mallya's behalf on the fourth day of his extradition case at the Westminster Magistrates Court, claiming that the Supreme Court had shown "unusual speed" in dealing with Mallya's case.

Warning over the further delays in such cases where personalities such as Vijay Mallya are involved, the apex court has asked for a reply over the issue by Friday. Citing academic research, Lau told the court that in India, Supreme Court "judges close to retirement lean in decision-making in favour of government".

Lau added although the Supreme Court is "heavily burdened", the Mallya case went to it with "considerable apace".

Mallya, 61, is fighting extradition to India where he faces charges of fraud and cheating after defaulting on loans to Indian banks worth Rs 9,000cr.

"I hold the Supreme Court in the highest respect but it is equally not disrespectful to indicate that some doubts are voiced about particular patterns [in judgments]", Dr Lau, an expert on South Asian law, told court. Lau also spoke about the adverse impact of a media trial on the fairness of the court trial.

"There is growing concern media coverage might affect all aspects of a trial from judge to witnesses to police".

He argued there was intense media interest because "substantial funds had gone missing in a developing country" and the prospects of fair trial could be raised in the trial court in India.

Lau said courts in India tend to be influenced by media trials.

Clare Montgomery, Mallya's lawyer, pointed out the rapid pace at which his case progressed from the Karnataka high court to the Supreme Court, despite the latter facing a large number of cases.

She also referred to another study that found several allegedly undesirable aspects including fabrication and planting of evidence, torture, death penalty, and abuse of the legal process in India to support the defence's claim that Mallya may not get a fair trial if extradited.

Reading from Lau's written testimony, Mallya's counsel quoted from an unnamed media report to claim that there had been "coercion" by Special Director Rakesh Asthana and his team over the banks in India to pursue criminal proceedings against her client. Lau agreed with her that a statement under Section 161 of the Criminal Procedure Code can not be used to secure a conviction in court.

Earlier today, the defence had deposed Margaret Sweeney, the Chief Financial Officer of Force India, Mallya' s Formula 1 racing team. Sweeney denied any secrecy in transactions between Kingfisher Airlines and Force India, and said that all the accounts had been audited.

However, the CPS arguing on behalf of the Indian government countered that assertion in its cross-examination, indicating that the reason such a repayment offer would have been rejected was that the banks knew Mallya had the means to pay back the entire amount due.



Like this

loading...
loading...

Latest


11 April 2018
England All-rounder David Willey Replaces Kedar Jadhav
He has two centuries and seven half centuries to his name, which have come while playing in various T20 leagues across the world. With an experience of more than 140 T20 matches, David will prove out to be the Trump Card of Chennai Super Kings this season.

27 March 2018
The Growth of Online Gaming and Betting Companies
Even though brick and mortar casinos make offers to gamblers, they do not come anywhere close to what is offered on the wide web. Alternatively, they can be used to learn about the game and the features it comes with as well as the strategies that work best.

15 March 2018
Server Requirements for Mass Mailing
The first means that the error occurred on the receiving side: maybe the client's account was blocked, or something else happened. Running your own email server may sound like a science fiction, and it may seem that it’s impossible to handle such thing.

12 December 2017
Sturridge considering move overseas
Liverpool striker Daniel Sturridge is so desperate for game time he is open to a move overseas in January. The fact is he is no longer essential to Klopp's Liverpool side and arguably expendable.

12 December 2017
Ed Sheeran Closes Out Capital FM Jingle Bell Ball 2017!
In the meantime, another insider told US Weekly , " Taylor had her own private party backstage at MSG tonight before the show". This is not anything they are stressing about. "Their relationship is very different from Taylor's past ones".

12 December 2017
Another pregnancy hint from Khloe Kardashian?
Why do people think that marriage equates to happiness? As for kids, she stated that she wants them when the 'time is right'. She's continuing to show her adoration for her maybe baby daddy with the sweetest Instagram message on December 11.

12 December 2017
Aldi's popularity with British shoppers soars as sales rise 15pc
The former also filed an increase in market share of 0.5%, taking its total to 5.1%. Mr McKevitt said that Aldi saw notable successes in the chilled aisle.

12 December 2017
Trump Spoke At A Civil Rights Museum. Civil Rights Leaders Boycotted
Lumumba called Trump to task for "his pompous disregard for all of those factors that will not enable us to stand with him today". His widow, Myrlie, was in the audience for Trump's speech and drew a standing ovation when he acknowledged her.

12 December 2017
TN: Six, including father-in-law, sentenced to death for hacking of Dalit man
The police had filed a charge sheet against the 11 persons, including her maternal uncle Pandidurai, running to 1,500 pages. Shankar, an engineering student, had married Kausalya a Caste Hindu girl, which was opposed by her parents.

12 December 2017
Varun Dhawan share his new movie poster on twitter
Varun recently wrapped the shoot of Shoojit directorial, which he claims to be one of his most challenging roles so far. And I am really looking forward to work with Varun and the team of Maneesh and Sharat.