Aadhaar Hearings: SC Now Refers To Cambridge Analytica Fiasco On Aadhaar Leakage

Aadhaar Hearings: SC Now Refers To Cambridge Analytica Fiasco On Aadhaar Leakage”

The constitution bench is hearing a batch of petitions by former Karnataka High Court Judge K.S. Puttuswamy, Magsaysay awardee Shanta Sinha, feminist researcher Kalyani Sen Menon, social activist Aruna Roy, Nikhil De, Nachiket Udupa and others challenging the constitutional validity of the Aadhaar scheme on the touchstone of the fundamental right to privacy.

Rakesh Dwivedi, counsel for the Unique Identification Authority of India (UIDAI), which administers Aadhaar, dismissed such fears, saying the authority doesn't have the tools or the algorithms used by Facebook and Google.

UIDAI counsel has however denied any such possibility on grounds that they neither have tools nor power to do such level of data analysis.

The counsel referred to the Aadhaar law and said the UIDAI had no power to analyse data at all and "I challenge the other side to show us the provision to that effect and if that power is there, then please strike that down". The Act precludes us from getting any.

The court said, "When we mean surveillance it is not real or physical surveillance but commercial surveillance".

First Concern: What is the goal of storing metadata?

The bench gave the example that even judges in an African country can get the access to his or her chamber by using his finger prints, which are used only for the goal of the entry and the problem was that such data was being stored at a central repository. Technology is a great enabler to surveillance.

"If the government wishes to surveil, it will do so without Aadhaar", he said.

UIDAI: "We can not even tamper with the servers".

The bench also referred to the testimony of Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg before the US Congress and said "you open the newspapers every day and see reports of how elections in even some of the most powerful nations were influenced".

"The 1.2 Bn Indians may be poor, but their data is a goldmine of commercially sensitive information."

Mr. Mehta responded that the court was right in thinking why the government should "intrude into the privacy of the entire population merely to weed out a few crores. but when tax evasions amount to Rs. 33,000 crore, it is a serious problem which Aadhaar linkage may curb".

To enable and boost offline Aadhaar verification process, the UIDAI has replaced the existing QR code on eAadhaar having resident's demographic details now with a secured digitally-signed QR Code which contains demographics along with the photograph of the Aadhaar holder.

Regarding use of stored metadata by UIDAI, Dwivedi said that the metadata was of authentication records and did not reveal anything about individuals.

Also, IDAI (Unique Identification Authority of India) has introduced the beta version of the VID (virtual ID) feature. Generate your VID from Not only financial services, even telecom companies have asked to link mobile with the Aadhaar number. "If the government wants to do, it will do without Aadhaar", he said. While it seems that the court is not convinced with the facts and measures brought on stage by the Aadhaar team, UIDAI does not seem to take a step back here. Take the instance of Cambridge Analytica.

Like this



30 August 2019
The FIBA Basketball World Cup Is Starting, Can Someone Stop Team USA?
The two Balkan sides have a bunch of NBA stars in their ranks, as well as players from the top European basketball leagues. The teams will then have the chance to rest for 2 days, before returning for the second group stage on September 7 th .

14 April 2018
Buhari is incompetent, says PDP senator
He said, "A few days ago in this chamber, we talked about the security of Nigeria". "This is our institution". He condemned what he described as the bitter politics of the opposition in the Senate.

14 April 2018
Ascena Retail Group Inc (NASDAQ:ASNA) Sentiment Increased, Because
State Of Tennessee Treasury Department holds 0.14% of its portfolio in Cigna Corporation (NYSE:CI) for 153,458 shares. The investment managers in our database now hold: 172.72 million shares, down from 178.41 million shares in 2017Q3.

14 April 2018
Traders Observable Stock:: The Interpublic Group of Companies, Inc. (IPG)
Barclays Capital has "Equal-Weight" rating and $92 target. (NYSE:CAT) on Friday, September 25 to "Market Perform" rating. On Thursday, April 13 the stock rating was maintained by Wells Fargo with "Buy". (NYSE:IPG) rating on Tuesday, June 6.

14 April 2018
#GC2018Athletics: Nigeria's Oluwatobiloba Amusan Wins 100m Hurdles Gold
Amusan braced the tap in 12.68 seconds leaving behind highly rated Jamaican duo of Danielle Williams and Yanique Thompson . This however will not be the first time Amusan will be having sweet romance with Gold in the course of her career.

14 April 2018
EPS for Diebold Nixdorf, Incorporated (DBD) Expected At $0.01
Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Company Limited (NYSE:TSM) has risen 30.51% since April 13, 2017 and is uptrending. It has underperformed by 61.98% the S&P500.The move comes after 9 months negative chart setup for the $1.14B company.

14 April 2018
CompañÃa de Minas Buenaventura SAA (BVN) Sets 12-Month High at $16.46
The Stock now has Analyst' mean Recommendation of 2.3 where the scale is from 1 to 5, 1 means Strong Buy and 5 means Sell. COMPAÑÍA DE MINAS BUENAVENTURA is a leading mining company producing precious metals and holding mining rights in Peru.

14 April 2018
Australian boxer wins Commonwealth Games bronze medal despite not winning a bout
Mr Lyonga called on the athletes to re-join the team, saying that they would not face consequences in Cameroon. This is not the first time Cameroon athletes have been reported missing from an worldwide event.

14 April 2018
Marathon Petroleum Corporation (MPC) Sets All Time High at $74.85
On Wednesday, October 18 the stock of Marathon Petroleum Corporation (NYSE: MPC ) has "Buy" rating given by RBC Capital Markets. As of now, Marathon Petroleum Corporation has a P/S, P/E and P/B values of 0.47, 19.42 and 2.56 respectively. (NASDAQ:SYNT).

20 February 2018
Best Affordable Car Gadgets
Thanks to the blind spot mirrors that can be easily fixed on your mirror, you won’t have this issue ever again. It’s certainly not a matter of luck anymore, like it would be with no deposit spins in a casino, for example.