Health Care

SCOTUS Declines to Hear Planned Parenthood Suit

SCOTUS Declines to Hear Planned Parenthood Suit”

The U.S. Supreme Court refused on Monday to consider appeals by Kansas and Louisiana to court decisions that blocked their ability to prevent Planned Parenthood from receiving medicaid funding.

Justices Clarence Thomas, Samuel Alito and Neil Gorsuch said they would have heard the case.

"Taxation without representation lives on today in a decision by a majority on the court that ignores the wishes of state leaders who no longer want to be coerced into funding abortion", SFLA's Kristan Hawkin said in a statement.

[W] hat explains the Court's refusal to do its job here?

The case was one of a number of disputes working their way up to the Supreme Court over the legality of state-imposed restrictions involving abortion.

The issue has to do with whether individual Medicaid recipients who receive services from providers such as Planned Parenthood have a right to challenge a state's decision to cut off funding to the providers.

"We are pleased that lower court rulings protecting patients remain in place", said Leana Wen, president of Planned Parenthood Federation of America.

Johnson told CNA she believes states should instead fund federal qualified healthcare clinics, which "outnumber Planned Parenthood almost 20-to-1 and sees ten times the number of patients that Planned Parenthood does every year".

The high court's decision to pass on hearing this case is certainly noteworthy, given so many on the left argued breathlessly during his confirmation earlier this year that Kavanaugh's appointment to the bench would result in the overturning of the Supreme Court's landmark 1973 decision in Roe v. Wade, legalizing abortion nationwide.

More news: Neo-Nazi guilty of murder over Charlottesville rampage

The move to defund Planned Parenthood in Kansas and Louisiana was in part inspired by anti-abortion activist David Daleiden and his organization, the Center for Medical Progress. That is barred by federal law.

Abortion opponents said they hope the court will take up the issue in future cases.

A pro-life advocacy group had presented evidence that Planned Parenthood was harvesting and selling fetal materials.

But the court not taking up this case means that most states can not, for now, effectively prohibit people from using Medicaid funds for other Planned Parenthood services, like screenings, ultrasounds and counseling.

But Thomas, joined by Alito and Gorsuch, dissented, insisting that it was the Supreme Court's duty to consider such prominent cases in which the federal circuits courts of appeal were divided.

"One of this Court's primary functions is to resolve important matters on which the courts of appeals are in conflict", Thomas began, quoting Supreme Court rules. Both Kavanaugh and Roberts sided with the court's liberals. What we have is an extraordinary group of dedicated judges doing their level best to do equal right to those appearing before them.

Similar defunding laws in Arizona, Ohio, Texas, and in have also been tossed by the lower courts. If so, they said, states may decide who is a qualified provider of health care. He also notes that states' decisions on this issue are heavily divided, and that "Because of this Court's inaction, patients in different States-even patients with the same providers-have different rights to challenge their State's provider decisions".

"But these cases are not about abortion rights".



Like this

loading...
loading...

Latest


11 December 2018
Armenia: Acting PM's bloc wins parliamentary elections
The former ruling Republican Party, however, still dominates the current parliament that was elected in 2017. Under Armenia's constitution, 30 percent of seats in parliament must go to opposition parties.

11 December 2018
Meng Wanzhou's Vancouver Home Broken Into, Police Investigating
Her second son is said to be studying at a school in MA but Ms Meng has not been back to the USA since March 2017. The company has projected 2018 sales of more than US$102 billion and has overtaken Apple in smartphone sales.

11 December 2018
Nicki Minaj Fires Back Over Criticism Of New Boyfriend's Criminal Record
Petty was initially charged with second-degree murder, but reached a plea deal in order to bring the charge down to manslaughter. Police records show that Robinson was shot three times in the hospital, and died shortly after in a nearby hospital.

11 December 2018
Ronaldo challenges Messi to join him in Italy
In other places some feel bigger than the rest, but here they are all on the same level, they are humble and they want to win. He's been embracing life in his new surroundings, while Messi has been enjoying life in his old ones.

11 December 2018
Theresa May to meet Angela Merkel for crisis Brexit talks
A government source said she will now make a statement to the House of Commons at 3.30pm outlining what will happen next. Speaking ahead of Mrs May's statement , the spokeswoman said: "This deal is the best and only deal possible".

11 December 2018
Macron to address France as protests shake government
With France's deficit and not wanting to flout European Union rules, Macron has scant wriggle room for more concessions. The message was part of a deepening feud between the U.S. president and his French counterpart Emmanuel Macron.

11 December 2018
Assembly polls: Counting to begin at 8am
Counting of votes for the five state assemblies would begin at 8 am on Tuesday and a clear trend is likely to emerge by afternoon. On 7 December, the Madhya Pradesh High Court had dismissed a plea filed by the Congress alleging EVMs malfunctioning.

11 December 2018
Putin Extends Condolences Over Death of Russian Rights Activist Alexeyeva
Alexeyeva, who trained as an archeologist, said that like many Soviet citizens she cried when the Josef Stalin died in 1953. In December 2017, she was awarded the Russian State Prize for achievements in human rights.

10 December 2018
New Teaser Reveals Stranger Things 3 Episode Titles
The episode titles for previous seasons have included some slight clues at what to expect, though they're still pretty ambiguous. Netflix confirmed on Friday, December 1, 2017, that there would be a Stranger Things season three.

10 December 2018
Nokia 8.1 to launch in India today: Expected price, specifications
The panel also supports Nokia's PureDisplay technology to offer sharper content, HDR10 support, and a high contrast ratio. The Nokia 8 .1 will run Android Pie out-of-the-box powered by a 3500mAh battery that is capable of 18W fast charge.