Health Care

Relax, meat might not kill you after all

Relax, meat might not kill you after all”

Public Health England officials told BBC News they had no intention of reviewing their advice on limiting meat intake.

The panel's recommendations for red meat intake by individuals were not appreciably different from that made by other organisations, such as the World Cancer Research Fund, given that current consumption in many countries was about 3 to 4 portions per week.

Researchers are hoping that this new study will influence future dietary recommendations. It also does not suggest that people should eat more of such foods.

They studied 12 trials with 54,000 people and found no statistically significant or important association between meat consumption and the risk of heart disease, diabetes or cancer.

Based on a series of five high-quality systematic reviews of the relationship between meat consumption and health, a panel of experts recommends that most people can continue to eat red and processed meat at their average current consumption levels. Scary headlines linking red meat with an increased risk of breast cancer need to be taken with, well, a grain of salt. The study showed that if Canadians reduce our consumption of red or processed meat by half a servicing per week, we could prevent about 8,700 or 16, 600 cancer cases, respectively by 2042.

Professor Tim Key, cancer expert at Oxford University, said: "There's substantial evidence that processed meat can cause bowel cancer".

The recommendations are "sure to be controversial, but [they are] based on the most comprehensive review of the evidence to date", Dr. Aaron Carroll, the associate dean for research mentoring, and Tiffany Doherty, an assistant professor, both at the Indiana University School of Medicine who were not part of the reviews, wrote in an accompanying editorial.

He added: 'As far as I can see, for the majority of important outcomes (death, cancer rates, heart disease), people choosing to eat less meat and those who are told to eat less meat or given less meat to eat have a small benefit, but this benefit might not be meaningful enough to impact on the population levels of these outcomes'.

The WCRF advises eating "little, if any" processed meat and only "moderate amounts" of red meat, such as beef, pork and lamb - with a weekly limit of 500 grams (17.6 ounces) cooked weight.

More news: Bernie Sanders' campaign announces it raised $25 million in third quarter

"This is perplexing, given the. clear evidence for harm associated with high red meat intake", says Frank Hu, the chair of the Department of Nutrition at the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health.

But many leading nutrition experts say that isn't the best way to judge nutrition research.

The new red meat review has no declared ties to industry funding, but the methodology for the two studies is the same.

"People need to make their own decisions".

Dietary studies are notoriously hard to do because people may not always eat what they say they do or may not remember. Reducing LDL cholesterol likewise reduces one's risk of developing heart disease, a very common condition that claims millions of lives every year.

"(The research released Monday) is a high-quality meta-analysis study and I think when people receive this information, they're going to be confused about the messaging about red meat and processed meat", said Taylor. The new analysis also did not consider environment-related or ethical reasons for avoiding meat, which are valid concerns as well. This report will confuse the public.

"We believe that authoritative organizations shouldn't be telling the public broadly what to do", he said.

He did not question the integrity, expertise and good intentions of the leadership team and panel, but he had some reservations about the "guidelines" they had issued.



Like this

loading...
loading...

Latest


02 October 2019
North Korea fires projectiles, after agreeing to United States talks
US State Department spokeswoman Morgan Ortagus later confirmed the talks, which she said would happen "within the next week".

02 October 2019
Former Congressman Chris Collins pleads guilty to insider trading charges
Chris Collins (R-NY) also pleaded guilty to insider trading charges and lying to the Federal Bureau of Investigation . Chris Collins is scheduled to appear before a federal judge for an expected guilty plea in an insider trading case.

02 October 2019
Severe thunderstorm watch in effect for Toronto
The rest of the week is expected to be seasonally cool weather as the temperatures continue to plummet. The agency reminds residents that severe thunderstorms can produce tornadoes.

02 October 2019
Sony Chops PlayStation Now Monthly Price by 50% Amid Rising Streaming Competition
Each month, the service will add a refreshed selection of marquee games that will be available for a limited period. Additionally, Sony recommends a minimum 5Mbps internet speed to support the stream.

02 October 2019
U.S. labour judge rules that Tesla broke labour law
The judge now wants Tesla to reinstate and offer backpay to a pro-union employee and to revoke a warning issue to another one. Musk threatened to take away a benefit enjoyed by the employees consequently for voting to unionise", the judge ruled.

02 October 2019
Federal judge rules Harvard's affirmative action policy is not discriminatory
Harvard is one of the top-rated and most selective universities in the United States , admitting about 1,600 freshman students out of 42,000 applicants each year.

02 October 2019
Shaq Drops Damian Lillard Diss Track After Guard's Podcast Comments
The song was in response to a September The Joe Budden Podcast interview that saw Dame say he was a better rapper than Shaq. It's a direct response to Shaq's bars where he demanded respect as an elder and superior player.

02 October 2019
Rutgers fires coach after 8 wins in 3-plus seasons
The Scarlet Knights have lost 14 straight Big Ten games and 16 consecutive contests to Power 5 conference opponents. Ash and McNulty's buyouts will be paid for by athletic department-generated funds, according to Rutgers.

01 October 2019
International Business: Ford forms Joint venture with Mahindra for Indian business
It will be operationally managed by Mahindra, and its governance will be equally composed of representatives of Mahindra and Ford. Both Mahindra and Ford will continue to own their respective brands and operate their own independent dealer networks in India.

01 October 2019
DOJ charges US man with spying on behalf of China
The FBI passed classified information to MSS agents using the USA double agent, who was paid for the information. He is due in court on Wednesday and he is now in custody in San Francisco being held without bond, per the AP.