Orange County Archive

Hudson Valley local record · Orange County, New York

Navy to move USS McCain to Japan for damage assessment

Ref. NG/21A7

In early September 2017, the United States Navy announced its plan to transport the damaged destroyer USS John S. McCain from Singapore to its ship repair facility in Yokosuka, Japan. The decision came just weeks after the warship was involved in a deadly collision at sea. The move was intended to allow for a complete assessment of the damage and to determine the final scope of repairs required to return the vessel to service.

The August 21 Collision

The guided-missile destroyer had been severely damaged on August 21, 2017, following a collision with the Liberian-flagged oil and chemical tanker Alnic MC. The incident occurred east of the Straits of Malacca and Singapore while the McCain was en route to a routine port visit. The impact breached the destroyer’s hull on its port side, flooding crew berthing compartments as well as machinery and communications rooms.

The collision resulted in the deaths of ten U.S. Navy sailors and injured five others. After the incident, the McCain sailed under its own power to Singapore’s Changi Naval Base for initial damage control and inspection. The Alnic MC sustained damage to its bow but no crew were injured and no oil was spilled.

Transport to Yokosuka

According to a news release from the Naval Systems Command Office, the plan was to move the McCain from Changi Naval Base using a heavy-lift transport vessel. This specialized procedure involves a semi-submersible ship that lifts the damaged destroyer out of the water for secure passage. The journey from Singapore to Japan represented a significant logistical undertaking.

The choice of Yokosuka was based on several factors. The city is home to the U.S. Navy’s largest and most capable overseas ship repair facility. A Navy official also stated that relocating the vessel to Yokosuka would allow the crew to be close to their families, as the port serves as the headquarters for the U.S. Seventh Fleet, to which the McCain was assigned.

Awaiting Full Damage Assessment

Upon its arrival in Japan, the primary task was to conduct a thorough damage assessment in dry dock. This evaluation would determine whether the necessary repairs could be fully completed in Yokosuka or if the destroyer would need to be transported back to the United States for more extensive structural work. At the time of the announcement, it was reported as unclear whether the Yokosuka facility had the dry dock space and resources to undertake the entire repair process.

Navy officials also noted that a memorial ceremony for the ten sailors who lost their lives in the collision was being considered for when the ship and its crew arrived in Yokosuka.

Questions about this record

What happened to the USS John S. McCain in 2017?

On August 21, 2017, the destroyer collided with the merchant tanker Alnic MC near the Strait of Malacca. The collision caused extensive damage to the warship's port side, flooding several compartments and resulting in the deaths of ten sailors. The ship was taken to Changi Naval Base in Singapore before being transported to Japan for comprehensive assessment and repairs.

Why was the destroyer moved to Japan instead of being repaired in Singapore?

The U.S. Navy's facility in Yokosuka, Japan, is its largest overseas ship repair installation, equipped for complex work. The Naval Systems Command Office also cited the benefit of moving the ship and its crew to their homeport area, allowing sailors to be near their families during the lengthy assessment and repair period. Singapore offered temporary moorage but not long-term repair capacity.

How is a damaged warship like the McCain transported across the ocean?

The Navy contracted a heavy-lift transport vessel for the journey. This type of ship has a submersible main deck that is lowered beneath the water. The damaged vessel is floated over the deck, which is then raised, lifting the warship completely out of the sea for safe and stable transport from one port to another.

Was this incident related to the USS Fitzgerald collision?

No, they were separate events. The USS Fitzgerald collided with a container ship off the coast of Japan on June 17, 2017. While both incidents involved Arleigh Burke-class destroyers assigned to the U.S. Seventh Fleet and occurred in the same summer, the dates, locations, and other vessels involved were entirely different.